10.21.2024
Margin Call

No bull market here. From Reuters:

Profitability at asset managers has slipped for the past two years and is likely to decline further through 2028 as investors increasingly opt for products with lower fees, such as exchange-traded funds (ETFs), according to a new study.

The study of 40 global asset managers including BlackRock, State Street, JPMorgan and Goldman Sachs by German financial strategy advisor zeb Consulting showed their profits in 2023 slipped to 8.2 basis points (0.082%) of assets under management from 10.1 basis points in 2021 and 9.4 points in 2022.

"The good years are over for now," zeb senior consultant Fränk Hamelius, one of the study's authors, said on Monday.

Over the past five years, the assets under management of the firms studied have risen by 8.8% annually on average, but their operating profits have only gone up by 0.7% per annum, it said.

Tiff Hanger
Nothing stops this train:

Nothing stops this train: the artificial intelligence funding frenzy continues to gather steam, as The Wall Street Journal reports that search firm Perplexity is in negotiations for $500 million in fresh capital at a valuation of $8 billion or more, up from a $3 billion figure as of this summer and $520 million in January. For its part, Bloomberg pegs Perplexity’s latest post-money price tag at $9 billion, likewise noting that investors approached the startup about providing fresh cash, rather than the other way around. 

Indeed, AI remains the shining bright spot in an otherwise dreary, post-ZIRP venture capital backdrop, representing 31% of total VC funding in the third quarter per data from CB Insights after garnering a 35% share over the three months through June (OpenAI’s monster $6.6 billion round took place early this month, fueling a stellar start to the fourth quarter).  For context, financial technology accounted for roughly 20% of VC funding during bubbleicious 2021, while crypto-related concerns have yet to top 6% in a given quarter. 

“You have this market divergence thing where a lot of the market is following the pattern of the dot.com bust,” Wing VC founding partner Peter Wagner told the Journal. “But then you have this subset. . . which is very closely linked to generative AI [and] is kind of in a late ‘90s type of acceleration.”  

Meanwhile, domestic VC firms sat on a record $328 of so-called dry powder as of March 31 according to PitchBook, perhaps setting the stage for further AI-focused shopping sprees. “We’ve seen momentum [investing] before,” Rob Siegel, management-focused lecturer at the Stanford Graduate School of Business, told the San Francisco Examiner Sunday. “We’ve never kind of seen anything like this before.” 

Yet as torrents of capital flow to the nascent industry, users and investors alike tap their feet awaiting enhanced employee productivity, increased revenue or other commercial benefits. “The window for experimenting is mostly behind us now,” declared Erik Brynjolfsson, co-founder of software firm Workhelix, at a WSJ-hosted conference earlier this month. “This is a year when you have to be expecting business results.”  Unfortunately, some 90% of generative AI products fail to make it out of the lab, estimates Databricks vice president Naveen Rao. “Accuracy and reliability is a big problem,” Rao warned. 

In the meantime, one potentially instructive use case comes to the fore, as the New York Post reports today that couples are “using ChatGPT to help win arguments.” One Reddit user lamented his girlfriend’s mid-quarrel usage of the chatbot, after which “she’ll then come back with a well-constructed argument breaking down everything I said or did during our argument.” Another Redditor offered some telling advice to the lovesick poster: “It’s literally programmed to tell you exactly what you want to hear. Discuss her actions with ChatGPT from your perspective and it’ll do the same thing to her.”  

Your mileage may vary. 

Recap Oct. 21

Stocks edged lower by 0.2% on the S&P 500 to wrap up the final full week of October in forgettable fashion, though Treasurys once again made heavy weather of it with 10-year yields jumping to 4.19%, up 11 basis points from Friday and nearly 50 basis points from Sept. 18, when the Federal Reserve saw fit to lop half a percentage point from the benchmark rate. WTI crude rebounded back towards $70 a barrel, gold finished little changed at $2,720 an ounce, bitcoin pulled back a bit at $67,600 and the VIX settled north of 18. 

- Philip Grant

10.18.2024
All in the Family

Have portfolio, will travel. From the Financial Times:

Major retirement schemes are concerned that the [U.K.] government could compel them to pour money into British stocks and infrastructure as part of its plans to revitalize the [local] economy, a move that could mean they have to buy lower-quality assets at unattractive prices. . .

“Mandation would . . . be a huge mistake,” said Paddy Dowdell, executive director at the Greater Manchester Pension fund, which manages about £30 billion ($39 billion) of assets, adding there was a risk pension funds would be forced to buy at unattractive prices. 

The proportion of U.K. pension fund assets held in domestic equities has tumbled in recent decades owing to a slew of regulatory changes that pushed corporate defined-benefit schemes into bonds, while funds have also derisked as they mature and wind down. British funds held just 4.4% of their portfolios in U.K. stocks, compared with a global average of 10.1% for such domestic investment — one of the lowest proportions of any significant global pension market, according to a report from New Financial. 

Price Club
Many happy returns?

Many happy returns?  The booming bull market in U.S. equities celebrated its two-year birthday late last week, with the S&P 500 piling up a heady 69% total return after reaching its post-Covid nadir on Oct. 12, 2022. 

That steep ascent tests the adage that trees don’t grow to the sky, as the broad index now changes hands at 37.2 times cyclically adjusted earnings, topped only in the dot.com bubble and 2021 and up more than seven turns over the past 12 months. 

Yet as Piper Sandler chief investment strategist Michael Kantrowitz pointed out on CNBC Monday, “pretty much all valuation models have pointed to the market being expensive for quite some time,” with the Shiller PE ratio remaining near 30 as the market bottomed two years back. Kantrowitz added in a research note that “stocks can remain at rich valuations as long as a ‘fear’ catalyst doesn’t arise from the usual suspects,” referring unscripted jumps in interest rates, unemployment or inflation. 

In the meantime, Corporate America supplies a steady bid. Publicly traded firms have announced roughly $1.1 trillion of share buybacks in the year-to-date through Tuesday, data from EPFR show, topping the $943 billion logged at this time last year to mark the largest such figure on record. “Fewer companies are participating this year, but the announcements per company are bigger,” EPFR analyst Winston Chua told MarketWatch, adding that “a lot of companies have excess cash, and [insiders]. . . are paid through-stock-based compensation, providing them with incentives to push equity prices higher.”

Perhaps tellingly, C-suiters are a bit more circumspect with their own money. Citing data from InsiderSentiment.com, The Wall Street Journal relayed last week that only 15.7% of officers or directors transacting in their own shares in July made net purchases, the lowest single month total of the past decade, with that metric remaining below its 10-year average in August and September. Captains of industry including Jeff Bezos and Mark Zuckerberg have rung the register to the tune of billions of dollars this year, while Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway has likewise raised cash at an accelerated clip (Almost Daily Grant’s, Sept. 12).

“Insider trading is a very strong predictor of aggregate future stock returns,” Nejat Seyhun, professor at the University of Michigan’s Ross School of Business, contended to the WSJ. “The fact that they are below average suggests that [future returns] will be below average as well.”

Indeed, today’s elevated valuations have previously augured slim pickings for the bull crowd. Apollo chief economist Torsten Slok finds that the S&P 500’s near 22 times price-to-forward earnings multiple implies a modest 2.9% annualized return over the next three years. Since fall 2009, the S&P 500 has generated a 14.5% yearly return on average.

As the rich (equities) get richer, one plugged-in observer demonstrates sticker shock. As The Transcript highlighted yesterday, JPMorgan boss Jamie Dimon supplied an instructive response to a share repurchase-related query on last week’s earnings call:

We do talk to a lot of shareholders and they understand buying stock back at more than two times tangible book value is not necessarily the best thing to do, because we think we'll have better opportunities to redeploy [capital] or to buy back [shares] at cheaper prices at one point. Markets do not stay high forever.

See the analysis “Tale of two decades” in the current edition of Grant’s Interest Rate Observer dated Oct. 11 a bearish call on “one of America’s great businesses.” The stock in question, a 2010-era pick-to-click, has since garnered a 505% total return while “almost exactly inverting the value proposition” on offer 14 years ago. 

Recap Oct. 18

Stocks cruised toward moderate gains of about 0.5% on the S&P 500 with one hour left in the session (when your correspondent hit the bricks), leaving the broad index on the cusp of new highs and on track for its sixth consecutive weekly rise. Treasury yields dipped in turn with the two-year note hovering near 3.95%, while WTI crude slumped below $69 a barrel and gold marched higher to $2,720 per ounce. Bitcoin advanced towards $69,000 and the VIX retreated to near 18.  

- Philip Grant

10.17.2024
Everything's Up

From the New York Post:

This good boy is top dog.

A man paragliding over Egypt’s Great Pyramid of Giza on Monday spotted the jaw-dropping sight of a barking dog atop the oldest of the Seven Wonders of the World.

The footage of the Egyptian landmark — built more than 4,500 years ago — shows Marshall Mosher soaring in the desert sky in a paramotor when he zooms in on the top of the pyramid to find a dog casually having his day.

Fortunately, the canine was spotted on terra firma later in the day, marking the latest soft landing. 

Ain't we got Fund
Structured credit: the next frontier of the ETF gold rush.

Structured credit: the next frontier of the ETF gold rush. A quartet of Wall Street heavyweights including Nuveen and BlackRock are seeking regulatory blessing to launch separate exchange traded funds tracking collateralized loan obligations (CLOs), The Wall Street Journal reports. Those newcomers would join a dozen incumbents collectively overseeing $16 billion in assets, capitalizing on a recent issuance barrage. New CLO supply reached $147 billion in in the year-to-date through Oct. 11 according to PitchBook, up 69% over the same period in 2023. 

The contraptions – featuring bundled and securitized leveraged loans – offer investors an à la carte selection of credit ratings and yields, with lower-rated tranches absorbing first losses and offering commensurately higher payouts. The triple-A-rated portion yields roughly 5.6% on average, compared to the 4.8% on offer for single-A-rated corporate bonds.  (See the March 1 edition of Grant’s Interest Rate Observer for bullish look at the CLO penthouse).

“There’s a great demand for yield, especially for assets that aren’t so exposed to inflation or big swings in interest rates,” Jared Woodard, head of ETF strategy at BofA Securities, told the WSJ. “We think that CLOs fit the bill, especially within a wrapper like ETFs where you have a greater transparency about what’s owned.”

ETFs likewise stand front-and-center in private credit managers’ efforts to bring their wares to the masses. Apollo Global Management filed paperwork with the Securities and Exchange Commission last month to launch its own fund, with the asset management behemoth proposing to infuse liquidity into the infrequently traded asset class by building out a trading desk to foster a secondary market for direct loans. 

Yet as Pensions and Investments reports today, Apollo’s prospective feat of financial alchemy is raising eyebrows in the nation’s capital. “There is a potential that, absent additional transparency and strong controls, Apollo could use its position as liquidity provider for the ETF to influence, potentially for its own advantage, pricing for those and similar illiquid assets that are held elsewhere,” Andrew Feller, former SEC enforcement attorney-turned senior special counsel at law firm Kohn, Kohn & Colapinto, told P&I. 

The lobbying group Consumer Federation of America expressed similar concerns in an Oct. 4 missive to the SEC, contending that the ETF’s proposed strategy “raises red flags” as the custodians will struggle to sell certain underlying holdings within seven days without substantially altering their market value. Under SEC rules, a registered fund must hold at least 85% of its portfolio in securities that can be sold within a week without affecting material price changes. 

September’s filing also notes that Apollo would commit to purchasing any of the proposed fund’s underlying holdings, with the caveat that such an obligation would be subject to an undisclosed daily limit. Since the firm would reserve the right to decline redemption requests, the CFA argues that “this further underscores the conclusion that a private agreement cannot transform an inherently illiquid asset into a liquid asset.” Apollo declined to respond to those critiques, citing the ongoing SEC review.

In any event, the financial innovation train rolls on unabated. As Morningstar chief ratings officer Jeffrey Ptak flagged yesterday on X, Tidal ETF Services LLC filed paperwork for an octet of funds dubbed “Battleshares,” which would feature levered long and short single name pair trades via a mix of vanilla equities, swaps and options across various themes. Examples include Nvidia versus Intel, Tesla versus Ford, Eli Lilly versus Yum! Brands and Google parent Alphabet versus the New York Times. Loren Fox, director of research at consulting firm FUSE Research Network, quipped that it “sounds like someone was designing a CNBC game show but then launched it as ETFs instead.” 

QT Progress Report
Reserve Bank credit ticked lower by just $1.5 billion over the past week, leaving the tally of interest-bearing assets held by the Federal Reserve at $7.003 trillion. That’s down $68 billion from the middle of last month, and 21.5% below the March 2022 peak. 
Recap Oct. 17

Stocks jumped higher at the outset but were unable to hold those early gains in a departure from the recent norm, leaving the S&P 500 flat on the session.  Treasurys came under some notable pressure as the long bond jumped nine basis points to 4.39% while two-year yields climbed to 3.96% from 3.93% Wednesday, while WTI crude edged toward $71 a barrel and gold notched another fresh high at $2,692 an ounce. Bitcoin saw a shallow pullback to $67,000 and the VIX settled just above 19. 

- Philip Grant

10.16.2024
Pen and Teller

Score one for Elizabeth Warren.  From CNN:

PepsiCo is unshrinking shrinkflation.

The owner of Lay’s, Doritos, Tostitos and Ruffles chips will put more chips in some bags to claw back customers tired of higher prices with skimpier bags. Shoppers have balked at downsized chips, cookies, paper towels and other products, widely known as shrinkflation, and turned to cheaper options or stopped buying altogether.

A PepsiCo spokesperson told CNN that Tostitos and Ruffles “bonus” bags will contain 20% more chips for the same price as standard bags in select locations. PepsiCo is also adding two additional small chip bags to its variety-pack option with 18 bags, the spokesperson said.

Now, how about that 75-basis point rate cut

IOU Tube
Open sesame!

Open sesame! Investors scarfed down Chobani LLC’s five-year note offering on Tuesday, as a hefty $4 billion order book helped the triple-C-plus rated Greek yogurt purveyor to price the $650 million deal – upsized from a previously planned $500 million – at an 8.75% cash coupon and 99 cent original issuer discount to yield 9.008%. That compares to Bloomberg-reported initial price talk of 9.5% to 9.75%.  

The bonds, partially earmarked to redeem preferred equity owned by the Healthcare of Ontario Pension Plan, likewise feature a payment-in-kind (PIK) provision, which permits the issuer to service its obligations with additional debt rather than cash in return for a 75-basis point yield boost. 

As those details indicate, booming asset prices have spurred ravenous risk appetite in the deep end of the credit pool, and across junk bonds at large. The triple-C-rated portion of Bloomberg’s domestic high-yield gauge now offers a 602-basis point spread over Treasurys, the tightest pickup since early 2022 and down from an average 829 basis points over the past decade (triple-C spreads dipped below 500 basis points in the euphoric summer of 2021).  Overall option-adjusted spreads as measured by the ICE BofA U.S. High Yield Index stand at 293 basis points, undercutting those seen in 2021 for the tightest of the post-Lehman Brothers era.

Considering today’s not-so-restrictive funding backdrop, the growing share of borrowers opting to pay in scrip makes for a noteworthy development. Citing data from Moody’s, the Financial Times relayed on Monday that PIK interest payments accounted for 7.4% of second quarter investment income among the business development companies (i.e., publicly traded companies which lend to closely held, middle market firms) under their purview, up from 6.5% a year ago and the highest such share since at least 2020.  As the pink paper notes, “the growth in these types of loans is one signal of stress in corporate America even as the broader economy expands, particularly for businesses that were leveraged to the hilt by their private equity owners and are now struggling with those interest burdens.”  

To be sure, PIK structures are not in and of themselves surefire indicators of distress, as some borrowers may opt to preserve cash to underpin rapid growth. 

However, public proxies suggest that such a constructive dynamic represents the exception rather than the rule outside the large- and mega-cap category. Société Générale global head of quantitative research Andrew Lapthorne relays that aggregate growth in earnings before interest and taxes among the bottom 90% of S&P 1500 components – exclusive of the financials and oil and gas sectors – remains flat on a year-over-year basis, while the bottom 50% of that expansive cohort has seen EBIT growth trend toward a 20% annualized decline over the 12 months through August.  

Recap Oct. 16

Stocks resumed their winning ways after yesterday’s pullback with the S&P 500 climbing 0.4%, while Treasury yields also finished slightly stronger with 2- and 30-year yields each dropping two basis points to 3.93% and 4.3%, respectively. WTI crude consolidated its recent losses as $70.5 a barrel, spot gold rose to $2,674 per ounce after testing its record high of $2,685, bitcoin remained on the front foot at $67,800 and the VIX reversed Tuesday’s rally to finish just below 20. 

- Philip Grant

10.15.2024
Monopoly Money

Call it not-so-free parking. From the Financial Times:

Australia plans to ban “dynamic pricing” amid rising anger from fans faced with soaring prices as they try to buy in-demand tickets to see their favorite bands. “We’re taking strong action to stop businesses from engaging in dodgy practices that rip consumers off,” said Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese on Tuesday, as he outlined plans to strengthen consumer laws after a Treasury consultation. 

The move by the Labor government comes amid outrage about dynamic pricing, where prices change according to demand. . . In Australia, dynamic pricing has been used for some sporting events, including this year’s Australian Grand Prix and Australian Open tennis tournament. Then fans complained that tickets billed as “in demand” on Ticketmaster’s website were being sold for as much as A$6,000 (US$4,000). 

But fans were particularly outraged last month when tickets to see punk band Green Day went on sale and prices for shows in Sydney quickly soared above the initial price shown. Tickets were sold at more than three times their face value at A$500.

Under the Hood
Things are looking up on Wall Street,

Things are looking up on Wall Street, if Tuesday’s slate of third quarter earnings releases are any indication. Goldman Sachs generated $3 billion of net income, up 45% year-over-year, as investment banking revenues registered at $1.87 billion against a $1.68 billion consensus estimate. Citigroup posted $4.82 billion in revenue from its markets division, eclipsing the $4.6 billion sell-side bogey, as the equity sales and trading division grew its top line by more than 30% year-over-year to $1.24 billion.

Though potent bull market conditions directly inform those upside surprises, relative strength in Bank of America’s core lending operations may present a wider economic indicator. Thus, the Charlotte-headquartered behemoth set aside $1.5 billion for potential credit losses, undercutting the Street’s $1.57 billion guesstimate, while outstanding loan balances rose 2.5% year-over-year to $1.08 trillion to exceed the $1.07 trillion analyst expectation. 

"Our customers' deposit balances and asset quality are healthy and we believe we have good opportunities to grow," commented BofA chief financial officer Alastair Borthwick, while CEO Brian Moynihan added that, though the cumulative impacts of the post-Covid inflation remain front of mind among the public, “overall spending activity is fine and the U.S. consumer is doing fine.”

Yet a diverse array of data draw a puzzlingly stark contrast with those sunny reports. The New York Fed’s freshly released September Survey of Consumer Expectations finds that the average perceived probability of missing a minimum debt payment over the next three months accelerated to 14.2% last month, up from 13.6% in August and represented the highest reading since April 2020. Notably, that sequential uptick was concentrated among middle-aged consumers sporting annual household incomes above $100,000. 

Squeezed shoppers duly plan to channel Ebenezer Scrooge in 2024, as a Deloitte-conducted poll of 4,000 consumers finds that planned holiday gift spending will reach $536 on average, down 3% year-over-year.  In turn, four out of five surveyed retail industry executives anticipate market share gains for lower cost private label categories.

Broad-based belt tightening is likewise on display in one lynchpin consumption category. Citing data from Nielsen, Jefferies analysts relay that U.S. mass beauty sales fell 5% year-over-year over the past four weeks with makeup products posting a 6% decline, leaving those two categories weaker by 2% and 3% on a nominal basis in the year to date. 

Finally, 24.2% of third quarter new vehicle trade-ins included auto loans in excess of the vehicle’s current worth accordingly to freshly released data from Edmunds, up from an 18.5% share sporting negative equity in the same period last year. Then, too, the average amount owed on those underwater loans reached a record $6,458 over the three months through September, up 11.2% year-over-year, while 22% of that negative equity cohort owe $10,000 or more with 7.5% on the hook for upwards of $15,000.

“Consumers owing a grand or two more than their car is worth isn’t the end of the world, but seeing such a notably share of individuals affected at the $10,000 or even $15,000 level is nothing short of alarming,” commented Jessica Caldwell, Edmunds’ head of insights. Peer Ivan Drury added that “it’s easy to assume that only specific customers trading in higher-ticket luxury vehicles are the ones underwater on their car loans, but the reality is that this is a problem across the board.”

Choose your own economic adventure. 

Recap Oct. 15

Pain in the healthcare and chips sectors helped preempt today’s bull market programming, as stocks fell to the tune of 0.8% on the S&P 500 and 1.3% on the Nasdaq 100 to erase the latest leg higher for those indices, while Treasurys caught a bid on the long end with 30-year yields dipping seven basis points to 4.32%. WTI crude was hammered by another 4% to finish near $71 a barrel, gold pushed higher at $2,661 per ounce, bitcoin rallied to $66,800 and the VIX advanced to 20.7, up just under one point on the day.

- Philip Grant

10.14.2024
Forces Majeure

A headline from the Baltimore Sun:

Army and Navy football both ranked in AP Top 25 for first time since 1960

Challenge Accepted
Mission accomplished?

Mission accomplished? Personal consumption expenditures (PCE) inflation data for September will register at a 2.04% year-over-year clip, if Goldman Sachs-issued estimates from Friday are on the beam, all but returning to the Federal Reserve’s self-imposed 2% per annum target after measured price pressures exploded to a 40-year high in the summer of 2022. That prospective downshift follows last month's 2.4% annual growth in headline consumer prices, which topped consensus estimates of 2.3% but still marked the coolest reading since early 2021.  

Indeed, the post-Covid inflationary outburst appears firmly in the monetary mandarins’ rear-view mirror, as demonstrated by last month’s supersized, 50 basis point rate cut. Recent monetary misadventures aside, Chicago Fed president Austan Goolsbee flagged the potential for insufficient price growth in a Bloomberg Television interview last week: "if you look at [consumer] expectations, there are some signs that inflation might undershoot the 2% target, and we want to be mindful of that too.”

A similar dynamic is on display in the Old Continent, as the European Central Bank prepares to convene later this week. Interest rate futures discount a near-certain 25-basis point reduction to the 3.5% benchmark repurchase rate, in the context of a 1.8% 12-month rise in Euro Area headline CPI over the 12 months through September. Disinflation is increasingly front of mind in Frankfurt, as “the risk of undershooting the target [is] now becoming non-negligible” according to minutes from the September meeting. 

“Avoiding a fall back into the pre-Covid world [of sub 2% CPI growth] will be one of the ECB’s biggest challenges,” Morgan Stanley chief Europe economist Jens Eisenschmidt told the Financial Times. The former ECB staffer guesstimates that the deposit rate will halve to 1.75% by December 2025 but added that “it is very well possible” that rates will drop beyond that level. 

Yet as policymakers on either side of the Atlantic revert to full-blown dovishness, some on Wall Street express their misgivings. Strategists at Deutsche Bank noted today that five-year inflation swaps, which measure investor expectations over the next half decade, have accelerated at their fastest pace since the March 2023 mini-banking crisis over the past five weeks.  

The Deutsche team likewise flags geopolitical turmoil and an associated rally in energy prices (December Brent crude prices have rallied to $78 per barrel from less than $72 as of Sept. 30), broader upward commodity pressure stemming from China’s recent flurry of monetary and fiscal stimulus measures and a return to positive M2 and M3 money supply growth in the U.S. and Europe, respectively, following 2023 contractions.  Accordingly, an inflationary revival is “an important and growing risk to be aware of, not least given it completely took markets by surprise when it emerged again after the pandemic.” 

See the Sept. 13 issue of Grant’s Interest Rate Observer for more on inflation’s potential resurgence with ways to potentially profit from such an outcome, along with the Sept. 27 edition for a closer look at one time-tested variable repeatedly proven to spur outsized price pressures. 

Recap Oct. 14

Stocks kept right on roaring Monday, with the S&P 500 climbing another 0.8% to log fresh highs and a near 24% gain in the year-to-date. The bond market was closed for Columbus Day, though an early selloff the iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (ticker: TLT) was met with a bid to leave that vehicle slightly in the green at day’s end. WTI crude pulled back below $74 per barrel, gold edged higher at $2,653 an ounce, bitcoin jumped above $66,000 for the first time since the summer and the VIX settled south of 20. 

- Philip Grant

10.11.2024
Print Julep

Drinks on Ben! The fat tail wags the dog these days, as a Friday Bloomberg bulletin demonstrates:

The consumers powering U.S. economic growth are increasingly those who are higher up the income ladder and likely enjoying a wealth effect from asset-price gains, according to research by Federal Reserve economists. 

In the two pre-pandemic years, average household consumption was growing at a similar pace across all income groups, the new Fed study of retail spending shows. But since then, spending patterns have diverged sharply. 

In the initial Covid period through mid-2021, low-income households increased spending faster than others with the help of public stimulus programs. But their consumption fell back after the last pandemic checks went out, while middle- and especially higher-income Americans have powered ahead. Overall, since the start of 2018, high-earning households raised spending more than twice as much as the low-income group. 

As a reminder, then-Fed chair Ben Bernanke took to the pages of the Washington Post in November 2010 to trumpet the central bank’s so-called QE2 asset purchase program, arguing thus: “Easier financial conditions will promote economic growth . . . and higher stock prices will boost consumer wealth and help increase confidence, which can also spur spending. Increased spending will lead to higher incomes and profits that, in a virtuous circle, will further support economic expansion.”

Who says economists can’t predict the future?

Emissions Still Grow
What's in a name?

What’s in a name?  European Union strictures set to take effect next month will forbid funds with the words “green,” “environmental” or “impact” in their names from investing in oil and gas, coal and high-emissions electricity firms.  As the rule stands, managers in violation must either sell those offending positions or rebrand their funds. Some 55% of the applicable investment universe holds at least one verboten position, research firm Clarity AI finds.

Yet as Reuters reports today, Brussels is now weighing a downshift of those pending rules in the face of financial industry lobbying efforts, as fiduciaries argue that such a crackdown will curtail funding via so-called green bonds, instruments designed to help wayward firms walk the environmental, social and governance (ESG) straight-and-narrow.  

“Our main concern is not so much the impact on a given company or fund, it is the signaling to green bond issuers and investors that regulators could disrupt the market with new rules,” Agnes Gourc, head of sustainable capital markets at BNP Paribas, told Reuters. Energy and power-focused firms account for roughly 20% of outstanding green bonds and have issued more than $70 billion of such securities in the year to date, LSEG finds. 

As regulators on the Old Continent weigh their options, virtue minded investors contend with the Richard Russell-coined truism that markets make opinions.  Thus, CNBC pointed out last month that European defense stocks have been on a rampage since Russia commenced its invasion of Ukraine, with shares of Swedish munitions manufacturer Saab generating a 252% dollar-denominated return since Feb. 24, 2022. “I think we had, like, 45,000 to 50,000 shareholders before this tragic war began and now have [more than] 175,000 shareholders,” Saab CEO Micael Johansson told CNBC. “If you don’t have any security [or] a deterrent effect, then you can’t talk about the ESG from other perspectives. That’s sort of the foundation of sustainability in my eye.”

Brad Greve, CFO at British defense concern BAE Systems, struck a similar note in an August CNBC spot: “You couldn’t even have [investor] conversations pre-Ukraine because even though you might be doing great things across the E, the S and the G, you couldn’t even talk about it. What’s happened since Ukraine, there has been a real change in attitude.”  BAE shares are up 111% in dollar terms since that fateful day in early 2022, compared to 41% for the S&P 500. 

Similar tensions between high-minded thinking underpinning ESG and practical considerations are on display stateside, as the artificial intelligence revolution’s insatiable energy needs force a realpolitik rethink. Asked at an AI themed conference in Washington on Tuesday on whether the industry can achieve its energy needs without crimping the fight against climate change, former Google CEO Eric Schmidt offered a telling response: “we’re not going to hit the climate goals anyway because we’re not organized to do it. . . I’d rather bet on AI solving the [energy usage] problem than constraining it and having the problem.” 

Recap Oct. 11

Stocks continued their heady jaunt as the S&P 500 rose two thirds of a percent to reach fresh highs, up nearly 23% in the year-to-date, while Treasurys managed a mixed showing with two-year yields dipping three basis points to 3.95% while the long bond settled at 4.39%, up from 4.26% one week ago (the bond market is closed Monday for Columbus day). WTI crude consolidated its recent gains north of $75 a barrel, gold pushed higher by nearly 1% to $2,665 per ounce, bitcoin finished little changed at $63,100 and the VIX retreated below 21. 

- Philip Grant

10.10.2024
Participation Trophy
Everyone's a winner in 2024.

Everyone’s a winner in 2024. This year’s resounding bull market has left jubilant investors happy to overlook disappointment, as the following trio of examples illustrates: 

Artificial intelligence remains the ticket in Cupertino, as Apple’s highly anticipated next generation iPhone duly stirred the bull crowd to the tune of a 21.3% third quarter advance (contributing nearly one percentage point to the S&P 500’s 6% total return over that stretch by Bloomberg’s count). Yet consumers have responded to the AI-infused device with a shrug, thus far defying hopes of a pronounced upgrade cycle. “The high expectations for iPhone 16 [and] 17 are premature,” warned analysts at Jefferies Monday. “A lack of material new features and limited AI coverage mean high market expectations of 5% to 10% growth are unlikely to be met.” 

The investment bank has company in that opinion, as peers at JPMorgan, Barclays and Citi have each trimmed their respective iPhone unit sales estimates over the past two weeks. Meanwhile, a Piper Sandler survey of teenage consumers found that only 22% of respondents plan to upgrade to the newest iteration, down from 23% and 24%, respectively, anticipating such a switch over the past two years.  AI hype and all, that downshift is particularly surprising since “the average iPhone among teens is about three generations behind the iPhone 16, meaning these older models could be due for an upgrade,” Piper notes. 

Yet the growing prospect of an iPhone 16 disappointment, in the context of negligible revenue growth over the past three years, has not dislodged shares from virtual all-time highs. Apple commands a princely 34 times consensus earnings estimate, compared to an average price tag of 22 times forward earnings over the past 10 years.  

Supply-related troubles likewise prove of little concern to Boeing’s creditors, as the aerospace giant contends with a high-profile work stoppage. Earlier this week, the company yanked its self-described “best and final” proposal – featuring a proposed 30% pay hike over four years – to the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, which has designs on a 40% raise. “When we surveyed our members on that offer, the response was overwhelming – those who participated said it was not good enough,” the IAM stated Tuesday.

The near monthlong work stoppage, which is denting triple-B-minus-rated Boeing’s revenue to the tune of $100 million per day according to TD Cowen, is attracting unwanted attention from the rating agencies. S&P Global placed Boeing on CreditWatch Tuesday, following a similar move from Moody’s in foaming the runway for a potential downgrade to junk thanks to a projected $10 billion cash burn in 2024 against $60 billion in total debt, with $12 billion of that sum set to come due in 2025 and 2026.  What’s more, 737 Max production is unlikely to reach management’s 38 per month target until mid-2025, S&P likewise believes, rather than the company’s year-end 2024 goal.

Such a defenestration from the investment-grade ranks would bring fresh headaches, with Bloomberg pointing out Wednesday that annual interest costs could rise by $100 million thanks to provisions present in $53 billion of Boeing debt which call for 25 basis point coupon increases per downgrade. More concerningly, relegation to junk status would force some investors (i.e., those mandated to hold only investment grade securities) to sell their positions, applying further upward pressure on funding costs. Yet Boeing’s 5.15% senior unsecured notes due 2030 change hands at just 142 basis points over Treasurys, down from 152 basis point spread as the strike began and only marginally wider than the 100-basis point pickup seen on Jan. 19, when Grant’s Interest Rate Observer issued a bearish credit analysis.

Nowhere, perhaps, is today’s friendly dynamic more on display than in the private markets, as Sam Altman’s OpenAI last week raised $6.6 billion at a $157 billion post-money valuation, the highest in Silicon Valley history. Those eye-popping figures accompany a torrential red ink downpour, as The Information relays today that the ChatGPT developer expects net losses to reach $14 billion by 2026, nearly triple this year’s projected $4 billion shortfall. Aggregate losses over the six years through 2028 will tip the scales at $44 billion, the company believes. Notably, those figures exclude stock-based compensation, which registered at $1.5 billion over the six months through June, roughly matching total revenue over that stretch. 

Though investors are plainly unconcerned by those anticipated losses (OpenAi’s valuation has mushroomed from $29 billion less than 18 months ago), Altman and co. aren’t taking any chances. As the Financial Times reported Wednesday, management is planning to restructure itself as a public benefit corporation, following suit from rivals Anthropic and xAI. The structure would allow OpenAI to resist pressure from activists “who might claim the company is not making enough money,” one insider told the pink paper. “[It] gives you even more flexibility to say, ‘thanks for calling and have a nice day’, they added.”   

QT Progress Report
A $17.5 billion decline in Reserve Bank credit leaves the Fed’s holdings of interest-bearing assets at $7.004 trillion. That’s down $68 billion over the past month, and 21.5% below the March 2022 peak. 
Recap Oct. 10

A hotter-than-expected September CPI print caused little consternation in the stock market, as the S&P 500 dipped a measly 0.2% to remain right near its all-time high, though long-dated Treasurys remained under pressure with 10- and 30-year yields reaching 4.09% and 4.38%, respectively, up 33 and 30 basis points over the past seven trading days.  WTI crude bounced back above $75 a barrel, gold rebounded to $2,630 an ounce, bitcoin stayed at $63,100 and the VIX settled near 21. 

- Philip Grant

10.08.2024
Double Take

As they say, 90% of success is just showing up. From KOCO-Oklahoma City:

An Oklahoma man is facing charges of stealing a vehicle after he couldn’t get a ride to court. The court case he was attempting to attend was for unauthorized use of a vehicle. The Oklahoma Highway Patrol said Kody Adams stole a pickup and drove himself to Pawnee.

Troopers said Adams was at a Stillwater gas station asking people for a ride to his court date in Pawnee. When he couldn’t find a ride, troopers said Adams decided to hop in an unoccupied LifeNet Emergency Services pickup and drive himself to court. . .  A trooper caught Adams as he was walking into the courthouse.

Adams said he was just “borrowing” the truck. . . He made his court case and was transported back to Payne County and booked on new charges.

Air Pocket
Where's the salt?

Where’s the salt?  A pair of D.C. lawmakers looked to put the clampdown on “big snack” over the weekend, as Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) and Rep. Madeleine Dean (D-PA) penned missives accusing the likes of General Mills, Coca-Cola and PepsiCo of a “pattern of profiteering” via so-called shrinkflation, NBC reports.  

“People have noticed that their box of Cheerios and bag of Doritos are smaller, but prices are higher,” commented Warren, who lobbied the Federal Reserve for a 75-basis point rate cut less than a month ago. She added that “we can’t let them get away with this price gouging.” 

Of course, acute post-Covid price pressures inform that rising political heat, as the foodstuff industry faces a soggy sales backdrop in the wake of bountiful price increases. This morning, PepsiCo reported $23.3 billion in third quarter revenues this morning, down 0.6% from a year ago and trailing the $23.8 billion sell-side consensus, likewise downshifting its full-year outlook to about half the prior 4% top line growth rate.  

Those figures – along with commentary from PepsiCo CEO Ramon Laguarta that “the cumulative impacts of inflationary pressures and higher borrowing costs over the last few years have continued to impact consumer budgets and spending patterns” – do little to raise spirits on Wall Street.  Citi analysts write that “we believe investors will continue to question the topline guidance for the fourth quarter” and beyond. 

A similar dynamic is on display in the quick service restaurant realm, as McDonalds logged a 1% annual same store sales decline over the three months through June, undercutting sell-side expectations of a flat showing and marking the first such decline since the 2020 plague year (third quarter results are due on Oct. 29).  

By way of combatting that unwelcome downshift, the fast-food purveyor rolled out a $5 meal deal featuring a McDouble or McChicken sandwich, small order of fries, small soft drink and four-piece order of chicken nuggets to cater to cash-strapped diners. As the Washington Post points out today, average menu prices at golden arches establishments rose some 40% from 2019 to 2024. 

“The consumer across a number of. . . markets, is being very discriminating,” lamented McDonalds CEO Chris Kempczinski on the July 29 earnings call, adding that “consumer sentiment in most of our major markets remains low” (see the July 5 edition of Grant’s Interest Rate Observer for more on the industry’s difficulties).  

As the post-virus inflationary impulse continues to reverberate, it’s not just shoppers and diners facing the squeeze. Thus, McDonalds filed suit Friday in U.S. District Court against JBS, Cargill, National Beef and Tyson Foods for antitrust violations, contending that the quartet “collusively reduce[d] the slaughter-ready cattle and beef supply” over the past nine years. Thanks to that “conspiracy in restraint of trade,” the producers allegedly managed to achieve prices “artificially higher than [they] would have been in absence of their conspiracy.”

No sacred cows here. 

Recap Oct. 8

Stocks resumed their ascent after yesterday’s downward detour, with the S&P 500 storming higher by 1% to reach the cusp of fresh highs, while Treasurys consolidated their recent selloff with a little changed showing as two-year yields dipped one basis point to 3.98% and the long bond settled at 4.32% from 4.3% Monday. WTI crude pulled back below $74 a barrel, gold retreated to $2,620 an ounce, bitcoin floated sideways at $63,100 and the VIX settled a bit north of 21 after testing 23 yesterday.

- Philip Grant

10.07.2024
Drone Show

When’s the next “Fed listens” tour? Michelle Bowman, Neel Kashkari and Alberto Musalem, presidents of the Federal Reserve Banks of Minneapolis, Atlanta and St. Louis, respectively, each made public appearances today. Monday’s trifecta marks a mere warmup for the parade of monetary ruminations as this week progresses:


 
Forward guidance, aweigh! 

Income as you Are
Last month’s supersized, 50 basis point rate cut has spurred an arguably curious response,

Last month’s supersized, 50 basis point rate cut has spurred an arguably curious response, as Reuters today highlights a “massive” inflow into money market funds. The category attracted a net $41.3 billion over the week ended Oct. 2 according to data from LSEG Lipper, following a $113.1 billion influx over the prior seven days. For a sense of scale, the $30.8 billion inflow for U.S. equities over the week ended last Wednesday marks the largest such figure since at least December 2020. 

Total money market fund assets reached a record $6.46 trillion Friday according to the Investment Company Institute, up from $6.3 trillion as the Fed began its easing cycle on Sept. 18 and compared to just over $5.6 trillion a year ago. 

As dwindling compensation does little to dim investor appetite for cash equivalents, demand for highly rated, lower yielding corporate debt remains exceptionally brisk. Each of the 20 U.S. investment-grade corporate bond tranches that priced last week broke higher in secondary trading, marking only the second such clean sweep of 2024, while the asset class enjoyed its strongest inflow since Easter over the seven days through Wednesday per LSEG Lipper. 

In turn, Friday’s hotter than expected reading of September nonfarm payrolls – and accompanying downshift in expectations over future policy easing (interest rate futures now price a 4.16% funds rate as of January 2025, up nearly 30 basis points over the past two sessions) – has done little to cool the asset class’s momentum. Spreads on Bloomberg’s gauge of investment-grade corporate debt contracted to 83 from 87 basis points, marking the narrowest pickup over Treasurys since September 2021 and approaching the lowest levels of the post-Lehman Brothers era. 

Meanwhile, the all-weather hunt for yield has pushed one corner of the stock market to history-making heights. Citing data from SentimenTrader, Bloomberg relays today that 96% of S&P 500 utilities sector components change hands within 5% of their respective 52-week highs, a phenomenon seen less than 1% of the time going back to 1953 and last observed in 2016.  That rate-sensitive cohort, which sports a 2.8% trailing 12-month dividend yield, logged a monster 18% rally over the three months through September. 

Recap Oct. 7

Stocks came under pressure to start the week as the S&P 500 dipped nearly 1% for its worst single showing in just over a month, while 2- and 30-year Treasury yields rose six and four basis points, respectively, to 3.99% and 4.3%.  WTI crude remained on a roll with a push above $77 a barrel, gold settled slightly lower at $2,643 per ounce, bitcoin caught a modest bid at $63,100 and the VIX jumped three points and change to 22.6, its highest finish since the aftermath of the early August market convulsions. 

- Philip Grant

10.04.2024
Tusk Never Sleeps

Extinction is transitory.  From the Daily Mail:

It has been more than 4,000 years since the last woolly mammoth vanished from the face of the Earth. But if one group of scientists is right, it may be less than four years before these gentle giants walk the plains of North America once again.

Ben Lamm, CEO and founder of Colossal Biosciences, now says he's 'positive' the first woolly mammoth calves will be born by late 2028. 'I like to think of what we're doing like reverse Jurassic Park,' Mr. Lamm told MailOnline.

In the classic films, scientists bring back dinosaurs by recovering ancient DNA frozen within amber before using genes taken from frogs to patch the holes in the dino DNA. But, unlike those fictional scientists, the researchers at Colossal Biosciences are actually working backwards.

Mr. Lamm says: 'We're not taking mammoth DNA and plugging in the holes; we're trying to engineer the lost genes from mammoths into Asian elephants.’

Highway to the Danger Zone
It's a wrapper's delight:

It's a wrapper’s delight: U.S. investors funneled a net $282 billion into exchange traded funds over the three months through September per data from Morningstar, pushing year-to-date inflows to $696 billion. That’s on pace to top the $900 billion full-year peak established in 2021 and leave the $1 trillion figure “well within reach,” as the typically bountiful fourth quarter gets underway.  Stateside ETF assets reached a tidy $10 trillion, up tenfold since 2010. 

“ETFs now offer nearly universal access to asset classes and strategies that were once available only to the world’s most sophisticated institutional investors,” Amrita Nandakumar, president of Vident Asset Management, commented on Bloomberg Television, adding that last week’s milestone is a “testament to how much ETFs have democratized investing.”

Indeed, Wall Street’s amply demonstrated ability to meet investor demand is once again on display.  For instance, 532 such funds now hold a position in AI lynchpin Nvidia according to ETF.com, up from 482 late last year (Grant’s Interest Rate Observer, Dec. 22). This includes funds devoted to tracking only one company, such as the GraniteShares 2x Long NVDA Daily ETF (ticker: NVDL).

Underscoring today’s saturated backdrop, Bloomberg warns today that “America risks running out of tickers for single-stock ETFs.”  Proximate cause of that shortage: exchange strictures requiring the contraptions to sport symbols approximating the underlying security, spurring some providers to squat on attractive combinations in behavior recalling the toilet paper hoarding seen in early 2020. “Competition for them has never been fiercer,” observed Gavin Filmore, chief revenue officer for Tidal Financial Group. “We can see market participants constantly grabbing tickers, especially as certain sectors or themes become more crowded.”

That urgency appears well founded, if Mr. Market’s warm welcome to a pair of newly minted, high-risk products are any indication. Thus, CoinDesk relayed last Friday that the Defiance Daily Target 1.75x Long MicroStrategy ETF (ticker: MSTX), which aims to generate 175% of the daily performance of Michael Saylor’s enterprise-software provider-cum-leveraged bitcoin speculation vehicle, attracted a cool $857 million since its Aug. 15 debut, putting the fund in the top 8% of ETF launches so far this year per Bloomberg Intelligence analyst Eric Balchunas. 

In turn, newly minted peer T-REX 2X Long MSTR Daily Target ETF (ticker: MSTU), which ups the ante via 200% daily MicroStrategy exposure, gathered more than $72 million in assets a mere seven trading days after its debut.  “Both have robust liquidity,” Balchunas posted on X. “I didn’t think there was room for both. . . it just [shows] how much ‘need for speed’ there is out there.”

No points for second place.

Recap Oct. 4

A hotter-than expected September jobs report did nothing to derail the potent bull market in stocks, with the S&P 500 climbing nearly 1% to mark its seventh weekly increase in its last eight tries, though Treasurys came under marked pressure as the long bond rose eight basis points to 4.26% while the two-year note vaulted to 3.93% from 3.7% Thursday. WTI crude remained on the front foot by advancing towards $75 a barrel, gold finished little changed at $2,651 per ounce, bitcoin rallied to $62,300 and the VIX settled just below 19. 

- Philip Grant

10.03.2024
Tales from the Crypto

From Politico:

A new HBO documentary claims to have cracked the true identity of the pseudonymous creator of Bitcoin, Satoshi Nakamoto. . . Satoshi himself is estimated to control about 1.1 million Bitcoin, but it's unclear if he still has access to the cryptographic keys to the fortune. If he did, this would put his net worth at $66 billion at current valuations.

Intriguingly, as the date for the airing of the documentary has drawn near, a number of high-value wallets from the “Satoshi era” have become active for the first time since 2009.

The program is set to debut next Tuesday Oct. 8 at 9pm ET. 

Twist and Shout
An unstoppable force meets the immovable object in private equity.

An unstoppable force meets the immovable object in private equity.  Easy-peasy credit conditions have allowed p.e. promoters to issue new debt earmarked for their own pockets like never before, as $18.3 billion in domestic leveraged loan supply backing so-called dividend recapitalizations came to market in September according to PitchBook, blowing past the prior single-month peak of $13.4 billion established in July 2021. The year-to-date tally through Monday stands north of $70 billion, nearly matching the record $76 billion logged during full-year, bubbleicious 2021 with one fiscal quarter to spare.

Yet a still-moribund IPO market and muted merger and acquisition activity following the post-pandemic tightening cycle starkly contrast with that ebullience. Private equity exits in the U.S. registered at $141.4 billion over the first six months of 2024 per data from Cambridge Associates, trailing 2023’s near $300 billion full-year pace, which already marked the weakest such output in over a decade. 

“There’s been such a lack of M&A activity and leveraged buyout activity that a lot of sponsors are looking at how to return cash to their investors, and if you’re not selling companies, one way to do it is to take dividends,” Lauren Basmadjian, global head of liquid credit at Carlyle Group, told Bloomberg Thursday.

On a global basis, distributions as a share of paid-in capital (DPI) among fund vintages spanning 2007 to 2014 topped 1.0 times (i.e., investors received more cash than their initial outlay) by year seven on average, relays the Financial Times, citing Preqin-compiled data. In contrast, DPI for vintage years 2015 to 2018 stand at less than 0.8 times as of year eight, while distributions for 2019 to 2022 have returned well below 20 cents per paid in dollar on average. Overall, the unrealized industry backlog of unsold portfolio companies stood at a record $3.2 trillion as of Dec. 31 per Bain & Co., double that seen just prior to the pandemic. 

“Exits and pressure to return liquidity is sort of the big new topic for the next 12 to 24 months," commented CVC managing partner Giampiero Mazza during a Bloomberg-hosted event in Milan Thursday. “A lot of managers sitting on assets bought at high multiples don’t really want to face reality.” 

Beyond dividend recaps, pressing cash needs have spurred other noteworthy contortions. Earlier this week, middle market-focused TJC announced the closing of a so-called continuation fund with $2.1 billion of assets. The vehicle purchased a half dozen portfolio companies from a pair of TJC funds established in 2013 and 2018.  

Such continuation funds – feats of financial engineering by which general partners shift assets from one vehicle to another while cashing out some investors (not to mention, scoring new fees in the process) –  represented 43% of the $72 billion in secondaries deal volume over the first half of 2024 per data from Evercore, a figure on pace to top 2021’s $134 billion in activity for the highest full-year sum on record.  Those machinations duly leave some practitioners cold. “We signed up for a 12-year fund,” Brian Dana, managing principal at Meketa Investment Group, groused to Bloomberg over the summer. “Now they’re asking investors to wait another seven years to get their money back.” 

Meanwhile, today’s debtor-friendly backdrop ushers in an accompanying downshift in legal protection for creditors, presenting the risk of excessive borrowing from liquidity parched promoters. Witness the proliferation of so-called high-watermark provisions – which allow p.e. promoters to borrow against the maximum Ebitda generated over a given period rather than the customary metric of average adjusted profitability.   

In other words, as Covenant Review senior analyst Ian Feng put it on Sept. 16, such terms “ensure that borrowers always have the greatest flexibility that was historically available to them, even if the company is severely distressed now. In essence the highest watermark rewards borrowers for bad performance.”

Feng likewise relayed last week that at least 20 deals within Covenant Review’s purview have included that feature, with lenders refusing up to eight highest watermark designations in September.  However, the analyst speculates that, in some cases, borrowers are using highest watermark provisions as something of a negotiating gambit to extract other concessions. Indeed, covenant scores remained largely unchanged in deals where lenders successfully pushed back on the HW feature. 

Might the bifurcated dynamic of easy credit and a bulging exit queue present broader financial implications?  See “Reversion to the boom” in the current edition of Grant’s Interest Rate Observer dated Sept. 27 for a closer look at this dynamic against the backdrop of private equity’s “newly unpromising. . . value proposition.” 

QT Progress Report
Reserve Bank credit fell by $34.3 billion over the past week, leaving the Fed’s portfolio of interest-bearing assets at $7.022 trillion. That’s down $56 billion from the first week of September, and 21.3% south of the March 2022 peak. 
Recap Oct. 3

Stocks edged lower again by 0.2% on the S&P 500 ahead of tomorrow’s September payrolls data, while Treasurys also came under some pressure with 2- and 30-year yields rising seven and four basis points, respectively, to 3.7% and 4.18%. WTI crude vaulted to near $74 a barrel, gold erased some early losses at $2,657 an ounce, bitcoin ticked towards $61,000 and the VIX jumped to 20.5, up a bit less than two points on the day.  

- Philip Grant

10.02.2024
Friedman Shrugged

There’s (almost) nothing more permanent than a temporary government program. From Bloomberg:

French President Emmanuel Macron endorsed a temporary tax on the country’s largest companies, supporting his new government’s strategy even as it departs from his longstanding pro-business stance. . .

Just under €20 billion ($22 billion) will be generated by boosting government revenues, with tax increases for wealthy individuals and large companies, as well as increased green taxation.

Inference Light
Artificial intelligence mainstay OpenAI announced today that

Artificial intelligence mainstay OpenAI announced today that it has completed its hotly anticipated funding round at a $157 billion post-money valuation. That’s the highest such figure in Silicon Valley history.   

Sam Altman’s outfit, which was valued at $29 billion in April 2023 and conducted a February tender offer at an $86 billion price tag, gathered a hefty $6.6 billion from the latest transaction. Though OpenAI expects to post some $5 billion in losses on $3.7 billion in revenues this year, the firm anticipates a swift top line acceleration to $11.6 billion in 2025. “AI is already personalizing learning, accelerating healthcare breakthroughs and driving productivity,” OpenAI CFO Sarah Friar told CNBC. “And this is just the start.”

Considering that backdrop, it is no small curiosity that key corporate cogs are seeking the exit. OpenAI chief technology officer Mira Murati and chief research officer Bob McGrew each opted to hit the bricks last week following six-plus year stints. Upwards of 20 researchers and executives have quit so far this year, The Wall Street Journal reported Friday, as disagreement over the firm’s original not-for-profit structure and subsequent ambitions have yielded “chaos and infighting among executives worthy of a soap opera.”  For his part, Altman commented Thursday that “I think this will be a great transition for everyone involved and I hope OpenAI will be stronger for it, as we are for all our transitions.” 

Investors are certainly counting on it. Altman et al. have managed to put the squeeze on their recent backers, the Financial Times relays, “ma[king] clear that [they] expected an exclusive fundraising arrangement,” which precludes any outlays into rival players such as Anthropic and xAI. “If a company holds all the cards, they can force people to do things unnaturally,” one venture capitalist told the pink paper.  

Corporate foibles and all, an avatar of the Covid-era venture capital boom and bust sees fit to throw its hat into the ring.  As the Information first relayed Monday, SoftBank’s Vision Fund is among OpenAI’s latest backers, chipping in $500 million. The deal marks SoftBank boss Masayoshi Son’s maiden investment in the ChatGPT developer, which had previously completed seven funding rounds by Crunchbase’s count.

As of June 30, the original $100 billion Vision Fund and its $108 billion sequel – established in 2016 and 2019, respectively – have posted a combined cumulative investment loss of $1.2 billion.  For context, the Nasdaq 100 has returned 330% from the start of 2017 and 134% since the outset of 2020. 

Meanwhile, a leading light in SoftBank’s checkered investment history likewise looks to saddle up once more.  As Bloomberg Businessweek documented Wednesday, former WeWork honcho Adam Neumann is getting back into the co-working game, rolling out a new format dubbed Workflow: “Like WeWork, it will offer space on flexible terms to companies and individuals, though it will aim to create a calm atmosphere with fancy artwork and plush furniture, instead of providing kombucha and beer at offices filled by twentysomethings run amok.” 

Then, too, Neumann’s Workflow will construct offices in residential properties it already controls and enter into partnerships to manage space it doesn’t itself own, pivoting from WeWork’s ill-advised decision to pair long-term leases with landlords alongside short-term arrangements from customers, with that mismatch leaving it exposed to swift and catastrophic drops in revenue in the work-from-home era. 

Indeed, as BusinessWeek notes, “WeWork burned through cash with an unclear path to profitability, which eventually proved disastrous for the company and its investors.”

Lesson learned? 

Recap Oct. 2

Stocks treaded water to the tune of a flat finish on the S&P 500 following yesterday’s moderate selloff, while Treasurys saw a bear steepening move with 2- and 30-year yields rising two and six basis points, respectively, to 3.63% and 4.14%.  WTI crude advanced towards $71 a barrel, gold consolidated Wednesday’s gains at $2,660 an ounce, bitcoin remained under pressure at $60,600 and the VIX pulled back below 19. 

- Philip Grant

09.30.2024
Room Temperture

Eventually, water finds its level. From the Financial Times:

Heat pump sales across Europe fell by 47% in the first half of the year as consumers lost enthusiasm for switching away from gas boilers, putting more pressure on the EU’s green agenda. . .

Under plans published in 2022 after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine drove up the price of fossil fuels, the EU set a goal of installing at least 10 million more heat pumps by 2027. Heat pumps heat or cool buildings by using electricity to transfer heat to and from the outside ground or air. 

They are widely seen as a solution to decarbonizing household heating, when powered by renewable energy, but their adoption has been hampered by cost, a lack of qualified installers and wavering government subsidy schemes. 

Germany had hoped to become a pioneer in the switch to the new technology, but a law introduced last year to encourage people to replace their gas and oil-fired boilers with heat pumps prompted a massive public backlash and the government eventually retreated and watered down the proposals.

Schrödinger's Bull
Call it the manic Middle Kingdom:

Call it the manic Middle Kingdom: The Shanghai Shenzhen CSI 300 Index launched higher by 8.48% today, marking its best one-day showing since September 2008 (alongside record high trading volumes) to extend its winning streak to nine sessions. After sitting on year-to-date losses of just over 7% as of mid-September, China’s benchmark gauge now sports near 18% gains for 2024.   

Coming in direct response to a torrent of fiscal and monetary stimulus from Beijing and local governments alike, that bull stampede duly sets hearts aflutter ahead of China’s Golden Week holiday, which commences Oct. 1.  “On the surface, I’m keeping my cool, but deep down in my heart I’m celebrating,” Shao Qifeng, chief investment officer of Ying An Asset Management Co., told Bloomberg this morning. “This is an epic day in Chinese market history,” commented GROW Investment Group chief economist Hao Hong, adding that “this is one of the happiest days” in his three-decade long career. The trio of picks-to-click in the Feb. 16 Grant’s Interest Rate Observer analysis “Commie value play” have since delivered dollar-denominated returns of 19%, 47% and 65%. 

Meanwhile, conditions in China’s so-called special administrative region mark a 180-degree contrast to the mainland’s pronounced euphoria. Thus, Bloomberg reported Sunday that China’s cascading property sector pileup has inflicted particularly acute damage in Hong Kong, as measured home prices languish near eight-year lows. 

Thus, some 75% of real-estate transactions valued at $10 million or above over the first half of 2024 involved financially distressed sellers, data from CBRE Group show, while corporate bankruptcies registered at 305 from January to August, on pace to easily eclipse the 354 logged during all last year – which was the largest tally since 2010. “There are more distressed assets in the market than I have seen in the past 30 years,” relayed Derek Lai, Deloitte’s global insolvency leader and China vice chair in Hong Kong.  

That dismal backdrop is now reverberating across the consumer facing realm, as retail sales sank 12% year-over-year in July according to the Hong Kong Chamber of Commerce, while the vacancy rate in Tsim Sha Tsui, a tourist hub replete with luxury brands geared towards wealthy mainlanders, stands at 15% per data from Midland ICI, up three percentage points from March. “The problem we are facing right now is that we have no customers,” Pamela Mak, president of the Hong Kong Chamber of Commerce, lamented to Bloomberg. 

Recap Sept. 30

Treasurys came under pressure with the two-year yield jumped 11 basis points to 3.66% following some less dovish than usual commentary from Jerome Powell, while stocks enjoyed their customary quarter-end ramp to leave the S&P 500 higher by 0.4% after treading water all day. WTI crude held above $68 a barrel, gold continued its pullback at $2,635 an ounce, bitcoin likewise retrenched to $63,600 and the VIX settled just south of 17. 

- Philip Grant

09.27.2024
Gone in 60 Seconds

Here’s a press release headline format bulls never want to see: 

Volkswagen Updates Its Forecast for 2024

Sure enough, the Wolfsburg, Germany-headquartered automaker had bad news to share after the close of European business Friday, downshifting its projected full-year operating return on sales (i.e., operating margins) to 5.6% from 7% last year and a 6.5% to 7% outlook as of July. Volkswagen, which likewise trimmed its forecast for global deliveries to 9 million units from about 9.5 million. 

Electric vehicle-related tribulations duly inform today’s dour state of play, as Volkswagen publicly weighed German plant closures and large-scale job cuts earlier this month in response to brutal competition from state-subsidized Chinese producers alongside soft demand. 

Thus, EV registrations across the Old Continent registered at just 92,600 in August according to the European Automobile Manufacturer’s Association, down a hefty 44% year-over-year.  That compares to an 18% annual drop for total vehicle registrations for the same period and leaves EV market share at 14% compared to 21% as of August 2023. 

Perhaps tellingly, waning appetite for the heretofore-fashionable battery-powered conveyances extends to society’s fringes. Citing data from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Axios relayed Thursday that four of the six least stolen autos in the U.S. last year were electric models, with thieves absconding with only 1 out of every 100,000 insured Tesla Model 3s. That compares to 49 stolen cars per 100,000 for the auto industry at large.

Cash Considerations
No 5%? No problem.

No 5%? No problem. Investors poured a net $121 billion into money market funds over the seven days through Wednesday, data from the Investment Company Institute show, pushing total assets to a record $6.42 trillion.  

Coming directly on the heels of Sept. 18’s half-point lurch lower in benchmark rates – with Fed chair Jerome Powell suggesting more to come – that arguably counterintuitive influx defies expectations of a swift migration towards higher-yielding, riskier assets. 

“[Investors should] find the balance of having some total return, which benefits from the price appreciation in bonds,” Jerome Schneider, head of short-term portfolio management at Pimco, argued on Bloomberg Television yesterday. “To do that, you need to step out of that curve.”  Jason Britton, founder of $5 billion fund Reflection Asset Management, took a similar stance to Reuters last week: “Money market assets will have to become fixed-income holdings; fixed income will move into preferred stocks or dividend-paying stocks.” 

Yet dwindling compensation and all, the category’s alure could be poised to persist.  Greg Blaha of Bianco Research argued this morning that money market funds primarily compete with paltry-yielding bank deposits rather than higher risk assets like stocks. Accordingly, “the idea of $6.4 trillion of dry powder being unleashed on risk assets is enticing, but we see this as an unlikely scenario.” 

Might the money market aficionados be onto something? See the July 5 edition of Grant’s Interest Rate Observer for a contrarian look at the virtues of capital preservation via Treasury bills and similar instruments, along with the Aug. 30 issue for an array of income-generating ideas as the easing cycle unfolds. 

Correction:
A wishful thinking typo in yesterday’s edition, which cited a $1.9 billion fiscal deficit over the 11 months through August. Of course, its $1.9 trillion. 

Recap Sept. 27

Stocks edged lower by 0.13% on the S&P 500 and 0.6% on the Nasdaq 100 to wrap up a mostly forgettable trading week, while two- and 30-year Treasury yields dipped by five and two basis points, respectively, to 3.55% and 4.1%, likewise finishing little changed relative to last Friday. WTI crude bounced to $68.5 a barrel, gold pulled back to $2,652 an ounce, bitcoin rose again to $65,700 and the VIX bucked the sleepy action by advancing to near 17, up a point and a half on the day. 

- Philip Grant 

09.26.2024
FInancial Conditions are Restrictive

From CoinDesk:

Moo Deng, a newborn Thai hippo at the Khao Kheow Open Zoo in Bangkok, has captured the hearts of many online through her cute antics. Now, she's the star of a $100 million memecoin.

The Solana token crossed the milestone capitalization earlier Thursday, becoming one of the few to reach that level from zero in recent months, CoinMarketCap data shows. . .

Holder count has zoomed to 12,400 unique wallets, with over $48.5 million in volume traded over the last 24 hours, a fan page for the token said Wednesday.

One trader made millions from the hippo heartthrob, with on-chain data from Lookonchain showing a wallet that turned $1,331 into $3.4 million by correctly timing the market.

TIP Your Server
Jaywalks the walk:

Jaywalks the walk: Fed chair Jerome Powell flexed his muscles during the recent Federal Open Market Committee gathering, corralling what had been a divided group into a near unanimous verdict with only governor Michelle Bowman formally dissenting from the 50-basis point rate cut.  Such an abrupt downshift is unusual outside of crisis situations, with 25 basis points representing a more typical increment.

“There is a clear success story in Powell’s ability to get all but Bowman on board, and he is a more powerful chairman now,” Mark Spindel, founder of Potomac River Capital, told Bloomberg. 

Investors likewise expect that demonstrated authority to translate to another lurch lower in borrowing costs, as interest rate futures point to greater than 50/50 odds of another half point rate cut to the 4.75% to 5% funds rate at the Nov. 7 FOMC gathering.  “Given his comments in Jackson Hole, and what we heard from him at [last week’s] press conference. . . I think chair Powell would lean toward cutting 50 basis points again” predicts Deutsche Bank chief U.S. economist Matthew Luzzetti. 

As Powell et al. pivot from the quickly obsolete “higher for longer” mantra, the D.C. spending machine remains at full bore. The federal budget deficit reached $1.9 trillion as of August with one month left to go in the fiscal year, up 24% from the same period last year and equivalent to more than 6% of projected gross domestic product. That output-adjusted ratio, which takes place in the context of a sturdy growth backdrop (second quarter GDP printed a 3% annualized pace this morning, rather than the 2.9% economist expectation), is the widest shortfall on record barring World War II, the great financial crisis and Covid. 

Suffice it to say, the imminent presidential election pitting Kamala Harris against Donald Trump doesn’t exactly portend relief on that score. The Wall Street Journal put it this way last week:

The country’s fiscal trajectory merits only sporadic mentions by the major-party presidential nominees, let alone a serious plan to address it. Instead, the candidates are tripping over each other to make expensive promises to voters.

Instructively, the Fed’s demonstrated E-Z money predilection, in tandem with Uncle Sam’s spendthrift ways, evince no particular concern among the political class over a revival in price pressures. “We are in a very good place,” commented IMF managing director Kristalina Georgieva on Bloomberg Television Tuesday in response to an inflation query. “The U.S. has helped the world economy stay afloat in this very difficult time.”  Charity begins at home: The Nasdaq 100 is up some 80% over the past two years, while investment-grade and high-yield credit spreads each reside near decade-plus lows.

Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen struck a similarly sanguine tone this morning on CNBC, responding in the affirmative when asked if she viewed inflation as sufficiently under control. "I always believed that there was a path to a soft landing, that it was possible to bring inflation down while maintaining a strong labor market, and to me, that's what the data suggest has happened," she added.

Might today’s freewheeling monetary-cum-fiscal backdrop provide a profitable opportunity within the Treasury Inflation Protected Securities (TIPS) realm?  Five-year TIPS now yield 1.45% compared to 3.55% for conventional Treasury obligations for that tenor.  

The differential – known as the breakeven inflation rate – now stands at 2.1%, down nearly 50 basis points from the spring and illustrating Mr. Market’s belief that headline inflation will indeed settle near the Fed’s self-assigned 2% per-annum mandate over the next half decade. For context, year-over-year CPI has registered at 4.2% on average since September 2019.

QT Progress Report
Reserve Bank credit ticked lower by $15.5 billion over the past seven days, leaving the Fed’s portfolio of interest-bearing assets at $7.056 trillion. That’s down $45 billion from this time last month and 20.9% below the March 2022 high-water mark. 
Recap Sept. 26

Stocks kept the good times rolling with another 0.4% S&P 500 advance following China’s latest bullish salvo overnight, while short-dated Treasurys gave back some recent gains with the two-year yield snapping seven basis points higher to 3.6% (the long bond ebbed to 4.12% from 4.14% Wednesday). WTI crude tumbled below $68 a barrel, gold rallied again to $2,672 per ounce, bitcoin jumped towards $65,000 and the VIX settled just above 15. 

- Philip Grant

09.24.2024
Shine a Light
If you bid it, they will come – eventually.  A stellar showing from the yellow metal in 2024 has evoked little more than a yawn from Western investors. Citing data from KoyfinCharts, the Daily Chartbook relays that cumulative year-to-date flows to the SPDR Gold Trust (ticker: GLD) have just turned positive in recent weeks, now sitting at a modest $644 million since the start of 2024 after reaching minus $4 billion in March. GLD, which is up 29% in the year-to-date, sports $74 billion in total assets.
Law of Large Language Models
Evidently, some trees do grow to the sky.

Evidently, some trees do grow to the sky. Artificial intelligence firms continue to make hay in fair weather 2024, as aggregate funding for industry startups reached $24 billion over the three months through June according to Crunchbase, double that seen in the first quarter.  The ongoing frenzy has duly pushed a trio of high-profile entrants further into the financial stratosphere as the third quarter winds down.

Thus, The Information reports that OpenAI rival Anthropic is sounding out investors on a new funding round which could value the Claude chatbot creator at up to $40 billion, more than double the startup’s price tag achieved early this year.  That provisional figure would represent roughly 50 times Anthropic’s in-house projection for annualized gross revenues, while helping infuse some much-needed capital; the startup anticipates upwards of $2.7 billion in cash burn across 2024, the Information likewise relays.

Fellow decacorn (i.e., startups valued at $10 billion to $99 billion) CoreWeave is likewise arranging a sale of existing shares at a $23 billion valuation, Bloomberg reported on Sept. 13, as the AI-themed cloud computing firm looks to quickly exceed a $19.1 billion price garnered four months ago and more than treble the $7 billion figure logged in December.

Meanwhile, the brightest constellation in the AI galaxy enjoys a full-scale bidding war, as OpenAI works to wrap up a super-sized $6.5 billion funding transaction valuing Sam Altman’s outfit at $150 billion. That’s up some 75% from the $86 billion seen during a tender offer conducted early this year. 

As the Financial Times pointed out Friday, the ChatGPT developer’s mushrooming valuation presents a quandary for home run-seeking venture capitalists, who often write smaller checks to nascent startups in hopes of earning windfalls equivalent to 10 to 100 times their initial outlay.  To achieve such an outcome, OpenAI would need to grow to $1.5 trillion and beyond, which would eclipse the likes of Berkshire Hathaway and Meta. OpenAI’s annualized revenues currently register at roughly $4 billion, while annual cash burn remains north of $5 billion. “How would you ever get a venture-style return on an investment of this sort?” one U.S. foundation chief investment officer rhetorically asked the pink paper. “I’m not sure what the math is there, or if there is any math.”

One thing’s for sure: a lynchpin of the bygone venture capital boom and bust is leaning headlong into the AI revolution. Citing data from PitchBook, CNBC relayed Sunday that Middle Eastern sovereign wealth funds have increased their funding for AI-related projects in the year-to-date by five-fold relative to 2023, while the United Arab Emirate’s new AI-focused fund MGX is among investors “looking to get a slice” of OpenAI during the ongoing funding round.  The New York Times likewise reported this spring that Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund – which famously poured $90 billion into SoftBank’s Vision Fund and its sequel – is “creating a gigantic fund to invest in AI technology,” with a proposed $40 billion size sufficient to render Saudi Arabia “the world’s largest investor in artificial intelligence.”

Recap Sept. 24

Short rates continued to tumble as two-year Treasury yields logged another multi-year low at 3.49% compared to 3.57% Monday, while stocks enjoyed another push higher with the S&P 500 gaining 0.25% and the Nasdaq 100 managing a 50-basis point advance, as Nvidia rode a sharp late-morning rally to a 4% gain. WTI crude rebounded above $71 a barrel, gold maintained its momentum at $2,659 per ounce, bitcoin advanced past $64,000 and the VIX settled just above 15. 

- Philip Grant

09.23.2024
Pins and Needled

Set them up and knock them down. From the San Francisco Standard:

“Let me get this straight,” John Mulaney said. “You’re hosting a ‘future of AI’ event in a city that has failed humanity so miserably?”

Everyone inside the auditorium at the Moscone Center groaned. Any notion that the award-winning comedian would play the corporate gig safe (and clean) were thrown out the window Thursday, when Mulaney, closing the Dreamforce festivities, started roasting his host, Salesforce, and the audience sitting right in front of him.

“You look like a group who looked at the self-checkout counters at CVS and thought, ‘This is the future,’” Mulaney said. . . “Some of the vaguest language ever devised has been used here in the last three days,” he continued. “The fact that there are 45,000 ‘trailblazers’ here couldn’t devalue the title any more.”

Mulaney then shared an anecdote about how he and his son, who is nearly 3, like to play baseball in their front yard.

“We’re just two guys hitting Wiffle balls badly and yelling ‘Good job’ at each other,” he said. “It’s sort of the same energy here at Dreamforce.”

Flightless Bid
Contingent convertible bonds may be going the way of the dodo bird Down Under,

Contingent convertible bonds may be going the way of the dodo bird Down Under, as Australia’s banking regulator has proposed removing the application of so-called additional tier 1 (AT1) obligations toward local lenders’ capital requirements. 

Rather than using those special purpose converts, known as CoCos, banks should seek “cheaper and more reliable forms of capital” by 2032, the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority argued on Sept. 10. A two-month consultation period is now underway. 

Last year’s mini banking crisis informs that regulatory proposal, as some $17 billion of the convertible bonds were wiped out following Credit Suisse’s demise even as the bank garnered a $3.2 billion equity value during a subsequent all-stock shotgun marriage with UBS. Vexed AT1 holders quickly filed suit. “The proposed changes seek to support financial stability at times of crisis with simpler and more certain resolution of banking in the unlikely event of failure,” APRA stated. “They are also aimed at reinforcing confidence in the safety of deposits in times of stress.”  Australia’s four largest lenders have about $26 billion of AT1 securities outstanding by Bloomberg’s lights, representing roughly 10% of global supply

Might the Aussie salvo presage a wider regulatory reassessment of the niche credit corner?  The rating agencies aren’t counting on it, as S&P Global predicted last week that “APRA’s proposal is unlikely to be widely replicated.” Peer Fitch Ratings noted that Australia’s “radical actions. . . may, in part, reflect the unusually high level of retail investor holdings of AT1 instruments in the country,” likewise casting doubt that the Old Continent will follow suit on such an initiative barring an express recommendation from the supranational Basel Committee on Banking Supervision.

Potentially shifting regulatory backdrop and all, CoCos have delivered fine results for risk-tolerant creditors of late: Deutsche Bank’s 10% junior subordinated perpetuals have jumped to near 110 cents on the euro from 92 following a bullish Grant’s Interest Rate Observer analysis (“A kind word for ‘CoCos’) on April 7, 2023, while Invesco’s London-listed AT1 exchange traded fund has generated a near 10% year-to-date return in dollar terms, topping the 7.8% and 6.4% seen from high yield bonds and leveraged loans, respectively.  

Yet, somewhat curiously considering today’s freewheeling credit backdrop, that strong showing has not translated to much attention from the investing public. As Bloomberg pointed out Thursday, Invesco’s ETF has seen assets under management shrink to roughly $1.05 billion, down more than $100 million since the start of 2024. “Flows haven’t really caught up,” Barclays analysts wrote earlier this month. “There was an expectation of higher inflows into the asset class once the Fed started its rate-cutting cycle.” 

Recap Sept. 23

Stocks fluttered higher in low-wattage trading as the S&P and Nasdaq 100 each settled green by 0.3%, while two- and 30-year Treasurys rose by two basis points apiece to 3.57% and 4.09%, respectively. WTI crude ticked below $71 a barrel, gold continued higher at $2,628 per ounce, bitcoin edged lower at $63,300 and the VIX finished just below 16. 

- Philip Grant

Use the search box above to access older ADG content.